These people are so-called Turkic-speaking people, but Uzbeks do not even say that we are Turkic-speaking, but they say it openly, and in all world documents and even Google (the translation of their language on the Internet), they call Uzbek and their language Uzbek.
My journey started 70 days ago from Astana, the capital of Kazakhstan. I also saw Almaty, I went to Kyrgyzstan and then to Uzbekistan. From Tashkent (the capital of Uzbekistan), I traveled to Shymkent, the third city of Kazakhstan, and from there I came back to Uzbekistan, and I have been here for 6 days now. Tomorrow I will go to Shahr Sabz, 90 kilometers away, this city is the birthplace of Amir Timur. Then I will go to Bukhara and Khorezm. After that I will go to Tajikistan.
During this trip, I talked with many people, including university professors. There are many points to write about; Some of them require more research and even travel to Tajikistan.
But!
The important point here is why and what factors within Iran’s government do not want to untie the knots that can be easily untied by hand?! And they fuel unreasonable wars and disputes between people???!!!
Türkiye claims that from there to Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan are all Turks and should be under the same Turkish key.
When I mention this to ordinary people here, they laugh loudly and say: We are not Turks. And they make fun of Erdogan and Türkiye.
The only people who are deceived are some Azeris of Iran and some people of Azerbaijan.
Two years ago, when I went on a research trip to Turkey, I realized that more than 80 percent of the people there are not of Turkish origin, but the overwhelming majority of people are Greek, Iranian, Arab, Kurdish, Armenian, and some old tribes such as the Pharisees, Hittans, etc. The rest have been resolved or their presence is not public or noticeable.
Earlier, Turkey forcibly converted two million Armenians to Islam by threatening to choose between death or becoming Muslims, and now they have dissolved in the society and their Armenian identity has been lost, as a result, they have been added to the number of Turks in Turkey’s statistics.
It was two or three decades ago that the Turkish government announced that anyone who speaks Kurdish will be imprisoned for several months (even years) and will be required to pay a large fine. It was that during my trip to Türkiye, in the Kurdish region, I saw that people spoke mostly Turkish. This work of Türkiye is considered a cultural crime. It is normal that every country has an official language of correspondence. For example, in India, the official language of the government is English, which is imported. However, banning the language of indigenous people in a country is a crime that is raised by mental patients.
Let’s go back to Central Asia!
Now I am in Uzbekistan and it is quite clear:
1- There are two very large groups of people, one is the Uzbeks, who never consider themselves Turks.
Another is the Tajiks, whose history is an important part of Iran’s history. They lived in this area to the east of Ferghana since several thousand years ago.
In the Museum of Kyrgyzstan, the history of this country starts from the 15th century. because the Iranians were not there until the history of that region was connected with Iran and had a history of several thousand years; It is a mountainous country, and Iranians lived from the small western part of it (Kyrgyzstan around the city of Osh), which begins in the Ferghana plain, to the western part of present-day Iran. These people were either not in the mountainous regions of Kyrgyzstan, or if they were, they lived in a very small number and lived a nomadic life, and there was no mention of the city or the government.
These people probably came from China centuries later.
2- The Tajik language has the same roots as Persian and Dari and has nothing to do with Turkish or Uzbek. Uzbeks also have their Uzbek language, which is not the same as Turkish. Perhaps the sum of Persian and Arabic words in Uzbek language is more than fifty percent.
Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan?
In addition to ordinary people, I also spoke with university professors in these countries. They don’t consider themselves Turks, even the head professor of the history department of Osh University, a city in the eastern part of the Ferghana plain, wrote for me the names of different peoples (tribes, peoples, nations, clans or whatever you want to call them) on a piece of paper, one of which was a Turk. .
It is obvious to scholars that Turkish was only one group of that list and is now used as the name of the language. Even in the book of the 13th tribe, it is clearly written that Turkish is a language like Arabic, which is the common and official language in many countries, but it is not the reason for them being Arabs.
The people of Kyrgyzstan say that we do not understand the language of Turkish people. The people of Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan understand each other’s language, but they do not understand the Uzbek language. Uzbeks also do not understand the language of these two countries.
They also do not believe that they are Turkish.
Note:
The two countries of Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan are in the Shanghai Union and are allies of Russia, so they do not change this relationship with Türkiye.
Tajikistan!
This country is never included in Erdoğan’s fiction and they consider themselves Iranians and Iranian speakers.
Racial tip:
The people of Kyrgyzstan and many Uzbeks are very short. Basically, their lower body is very short, so the height of women is between 140 and 150 cm. Men are also not much taller than women. This physics does not fit with Iranian Azeris.
Now, with this summary, I present the serious criticism again in a more expressive form:
Which Zionist, Freemason, Westernist, anti-Iranian, anti-Iranian and anti-humanist force is sitting in Iran’s government and has so much power that it does not allow people’s misunderstanding to be prevented by clarifying these points to the general public in order to prevent worthless and baseless debates and then the possibility of war. To be internalized and analyzed???!!!
Which force does not want these points to be clarified for the people of Azerbaijan, so that they too get out of the misunderstanding.
This is a great betrayal of the country, and its agents must be identified and brought to court.
November 30, 2024
Samarkand – Uzbekistan
The philosopher of the school
M. Hassan Baygan
